Reviews

The Only Living Pickpocket in New York

Pickpockets probably don’t get a pension or collect social security. I’m sure some have retirement figured out, and, yet, I imagine many others do not. That is if they become old enough to retire at all. I can’t imagine the lifespan of career thieves is above average, can you? But all I know about the subject I get from movies, so I cannot really say.

Harry (John Turturro) is the ultimate flawed hero. We don’t know how old he is, but he sure as Hell ain’t young. He steals most every day — watches, phones, wallets, what there is to steal. I feel like this is a profession slowly being eradicated, like haberdasher or apothecary. The market for stolen phones is next-to-nil. I suppose there are people who still wear watches, but I know fewer and fewer these days – your phone tells time; why would you need an accessory? His age makes him a bit of a Luddite; high tech is a turn-off. But that’s where the money is in 2026. His local pawn guy (Steve Buscemi) feels the pain; he prefers gold. Do people still wear gold?

It’s hard to imagine Harry as a guy who makes “an honest day’s wage.” And yet, he kinda does. He roams the city and subway looking for marks. At the end of his tiresome daily “shift,” he comes home to a catatonic wife. Of course, the elevator doesn’t work in their building, so he has to carry her up to their apartment on the second floor. (How long is he gonna be able to keep doing that?) Harry feels like an anachronism. His activities and lifestyle suggest a different age.

That last part couldn’t be truer when Harry thieves from a well-connected manchild outside a bar. The mechanics of the theft a perfect, but Harry hasn’t accounted for video cameras capturing his crimes and likeness. It takes very little for a well-connected douchebag to track Harry down. Uh oh.

The thing I like the most about the film is that we care enough about Harry to want to see he and his catatonic wife survive the unintentional mob hit. Such seems unlikely, especially when we realize what Harry has stolen. Harry isn’t a good man. He steals. He has a kid that he never visits. His life is an endless series of robberies, but compared to the twenty-something jerk, we sure-as-Hell want him to come out on top.

The Only Living Pickpocket in New York is among my delightful surprises on the year. I cannot say I love John Turturro, and giving him a film to carry in which he plays an aging thief seems like cinematic suicide. I mean, you must know that it is unlikely this film will make back whatever is invested in it. And yet, of all the ways this film could have gone, I think it chose the best path. I was very invested in this character, and extremely pleased with the resolution, even if it didn’t necessarily describe optimal outcome. I have no idea who really wants to see such a film, but if you do, there are many, many worse. AS NYC tales go, I’ll take Pickpocket over Marty Supreme any day of the week and twice on Sunday.

There once was a pickpocket named Harry
He found aging half-drag and half-scary
And then this poor schlob
Stole from the mob
Time to dial up your cinematic good fairy

Rated R, 88 Minutes
Director: Noah Segan
Writer: Noah Segan
Genre: Surprise enjoyment
Type of being most likely to enjoy this film: People who embrace ambiguity
Type of being least likely to enjoy this film: The rest

Leave a Reply