Reviews

The Cat in the Hat

There are better Dr. Seuss books to adapt. You know that, right? I mean, I know we just did The Lorax, but -let’s face it- it’s still quite relevant and I am certain nobody with the ability to make a global difference has learned the message yet. The modern age doesn’t lack for a need. Sneetches talks to us about tolerance, Green Eggs and Ham discusses dietary restrictions, Fox in Socks discusses foreign labor exploitation. The Cat in the Hat, however … The Cat in the Hat has to be shoved into a moral box sideways.

The Cat in the Hat is a book about two bored and, hence, easily influenced children in need of entertainment. They don’t really care what kind of entertainment and thus allow the literary equivalent of a carnival barker/snake oil salesman to show them an afternoon away from tedium. Their fun is interrupted periodically by a killjoy goldfish, but it turns out that stoolie bitch goldfish is actually the voice of reason. It’s kinda hard to fit that narrative into something that isn’t downer without changing it significantly.

So they changed it significantly.

Did it help? Yes.
Is this now a winning story? Not quite.

Gabby and Sebastian are the bored kids. Their mom has just moved the trio from *more promising place* to *less promising place*. Gabby, especially, isn’t a fan. Meanwhile, in fantasy land, The Cat in the Hat (voice of Bill Hader) has a job (!) He works at the Institute for the Institution of Imagination and Inspiration, LLC, with other rhyming delights such as “Pig in a Wig” and, my favorite, “Giraffe with a Carafe.” Cat doesn’t play by the rules! He uses his magical shenanigans hat to create chaos and instability. There is good argument to be made that the Cat only cares about showing himself a good time. The movie makes this argument, in fact, but proceeds to back away from it in in the climax. The problem is it still applies.

I wouldn’t quite call the Cat “Trumpian,” but it seems pretty clear to even the most casual of observers that The Cat is a self-loving hedonist. So far this kinda sounds like Monsters Inc. with a focus on Randall … well, a happier, less scary version of Randall. Yet, still, a creature employed to screw with human children not blink twice about how they feel about it.

Luckily, The Cat can use magic, immediately turning the couch into a vehicle, granting the fish the power of speech, and beseeching the kids to explore cardboard boxes, which are somehow revered in this silly universe as the best things ever. In a way, I take the film’s POV – a cardboard box is potential mystery, history, and amusement park all in one. In another way, a cardboard box is just as often “dishes.”

The Cat introduces the kids to the “Go-Backer,” a portable time machine that Gabby immediately identifies as a tool to return her life to a stage where she enjoyed it. It takes about five seconds after introduction for these guys to lose their time machine, hence requiring the need for a journey to the cardboard jungle. Random chaos isn’t enough at this point, so the film introduces a villain the “Something,” a dragon-like creature also after the time machine.

And as if this all wasn’t silly enough, The Cat has several layers of corporate bureaucracy to live down. His boss is not a fan. Gee, I wonder why.
Searching through the box with mom’s memories, The Cat recognizes her as another client he almost cared about but kinda didn’t. And no amount of screenplay backpeddle is going to make me think otherwise.

You might get the impression here that I didn’t like The Cat in the Hat. I don’t go that far. As far as adventures go, I liked it just fine. Hey, there’s magic and wonder and delight and danger. As for the other stuff, though, I find The Cat a bit of a selfish narcissist; I think the “Go-Backer” is a tool invented to relieve one of responsibility, and I find that however much I much *want* The Cat to be a good guy, I think the film lets him off the hook so as not to spoil a happy ending for your child. I think The Cat backhands his way into favor without actually doing the work of creating more well-adjusted children, which is the point of his “job.” Waffles (Matt Berry) the goldfish strikes me as a far better role model for the kids, regardless of how different he seems from his novel-bound doppelganger.

This is a kinda fun film with a kinda good message that is kinda half-assed with magical movie thinking. Sure, see it once, but don’t expect to get great things out of The Cat in the Hat upon repeated views. Still, it beats the Hell out of the 2003 version.

I kinda like your colors bright
I kinda like your thoughts on “right”

I kinda like your 3D thing
I kinda like your Cat world zing

I kinda like the boy and girl
I’ll wait for the plot to unfurl

But I do not like your selfish Cat
I do not like think that he’s “all that”

I do not like your petty quarrels
I do not like your pithy morals

I will not laud this film, no ma’am
I’ll praise it lightly, Frog I am

Rated PG, 107 Minutes
Director: Alessandro Carloni, Erica Rivinoja
Writer: Caroline Williams, Erica Rivinoja, Alessandro Carloni
Genre: Chaos
Type of being most likely to enjoy this film: How desperate are you for an uplifting message?
Type of being least likely to enjoy this film: “He’s kind of a selfish jerk”

Leave a Reply